Reviews and Comments

Reverend Erik

arnemancy@grimoire.social

Joined 1 year ago

Moderator/admin of Grimoire.Social and the strange quark behind the Arnemancy podcast. A great lover of books. A collector of many strange volumes. Show me your spooky grimoires!

This link opens in a pop-up window

Dan Attrell, David Porreca: Picatrix : a medieval treatise on astral magic (2019, Penn State University Press) 5 stars

A must-have volume for any astrologer or magician

5 stars

There are two Picatrix translations that get used by practitioners these days: this one, and the Warnock/Greer one. Both are excellent, but I prefer this one, and this is why: Attrell and Porreca have an academic approach to translation that lends itself to copious footnotes and careful, historical consideration of strange terms. They also label portions of the text by section and paragraph number, making it much easier to share citations with others. While the Warnock/Greer translation may be targeted at practitioners, I believe that practitioners can get even more out of this one, just from its ease of reference and excellent indices and appendices.

Nigel Pennick: Witchcraft and Secret Societies of Rural England (2019, Inner Traditions International, Limited, Destiny Books) 5 stars

A fascinating trip through nearly forgotten history

5 stars

Rural England has a very rich and mostly ignored history of secret societies and folk magic. This book reveals a ton of fascinating lore about both. For historians of secret societies such as Freemasonry, there are many interesting threads in this book that tie the Craft to earlier trade guilds and local initiatory traditions. For those interested in hedge magic and witchcraft, the collection of rites, rituals, and traditions that this book uncovers is AMAZING. The toadmen alone are worth the price of admission!

commented on Black Abbot, White Magic by Frater Acher (Holy Daimon Cycle, #2)

Frater Acher, Johannes Trithemius, Klaus Arnold: Black Abbot, White Magic (Paperback, Bibliotheque Rouge, Scarlet Imprint) 3 stars

This book includes the first full English translations of two angelic grimoires, reveals the construction …

This book was pretty good, and while I got a lot out of it, I didn't really get what I needed. I was looking for more depth regarding Trithemius's work on steganography, because I was trying to link it to more Renaissance cryptography stuff. So I enjoyed it, but felt a little let down. Probably my fault.

M. David Litwa: Hermetica II (Hardcover, 2018, Cambridge University Press) 4 stars

This is an amazing and much-needed collection. It contains the first modern English translations of most Hermetic fragments since G.R.S. Mead, and for that it is truly worth it. However, the quality of the binding on the hardcover version of this is truly terrible; it feels like a very cheap book. The contents are great but the actual physical book leaves much to be desired. Go paperback if possible.